Papermaster leaves Apple – not before time
♫ Monday, August 9th, 2010A leading Manchester MD gives his no-holds-barred take on the latest development in the iPhone 4 antenna saga…
News has emerged that the man pretty much at the centre of the Apple iPhone 4 ‘antennagate’ fiasco has left the company under brisk circumstances. Did he jump or was he pushed? That’s something that will be no doubt be divulged in due time, but the big question on my lips is how did he hold on to his seat for this long?
If this guy was operating under me, he would have been out of the door the moment the whistle was blown on this whole sorry saga. Some of you may take umbrage with this unreconstructed approach to human resources, but this is the corporate world we are living in – not the public sector. Simple fact is that if people make mistakes, especially if they make mistakes that end up costing the business thousands upon thousands of pounds (as Apple’s ‘free bumper case’ ploy is bound to) then they have to go.
And what was this guy’s mistake? The way I see it, the testing done on the new piece of kit was insufficient. What’s more, the solution to the antenna troubles – plonking a case around the body of the phone – betrays the one major flaw in the company’s testing plan. All real world beta-ing was done inside hollowed-out iPhone 3GS cases, so as to deter potential snoopers from the scent of the new handset (remember the chap who lost his in a bar, people thought it was just another iPhone until they checked it out more closely). As a result of this, no one noticed that there was even a problem with it until it was in the hands of Joe Public.
I suppose in a business community like Manchester’s, things are a bit more goldfish bowl; you’d think there would be less pressure compared to the huge global conglomerates but in a strange way the rivalry – and the cost of any mistakes – is actually very intense. That’s why anyone who’d dropped the ball in such a spectacular way at my firm would have to go and why I applaud the fact that Mark Papermaster no longer works at Apple – whether that was his choice or not.